Matthews faces up to 45 years in prison after entering a plea agreement with federal prosecutors, according to the announcement by the U.S. Attorney for the District of Connecticut John H. Durham, along with representatives of the FBI and the IRS. Matthews asserts that the district court should have restored the parties to the status quo ante that existed prior to the seizure of the document. Given the potential factual questions surrounding this and other issues, we believe that the district court is in the best position to determine how to restore the pre-seizure status quo ante if it determines that returning the parties to the post-seizure, pre-complaint status quo ante is inappropriate.3 Whatever method the district court chooses should fully preserve the parties' ability to pursue their ownership claims in other proceedings. As part of last weeks filings, Evans signed a statement of agreed facts that outlined how Robert Matthews, Laudano and others worked to purchase the property in Washington Depot for Matthews benefit. Evans statement said that at some point he learned that Matthews had lost the house to foreclosure and that Laudano had planned to purchase the residence as a straw buyer for Matthews., The statement continued: To help effectuate this sale, Mr. Evans signed and sent (an emailed) letter dated February 3, 2014, to a company, Auction.com, who was working to sell the property on behalf of the bank that had foreclosed on the property, J.P. Morgan Chase Bank.. Defendant LESLIE R. EVANS ("EVANS") was a real estate attorney and a resident of Florida. Mr. Matthews, 46, has said he first met Mr. Rowland more than 20 years ago in Waterbury, where Mr. Rowland grew up. In March 2018, on the same day that Robert Matthews was taken into custody, real estate attorney Leslie R. Evans was arrested at his Palm Beach home. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Real estate developer Robert V. Matthews pleaded guilty today in Connecticut in a criminal case involving investor funds earmarked to renovate the long-stagnant Palm House hotel-condominium in Palm Beach, according to a joint statement released by U.S. officials. His deals, meanwhile, often relied on millions in state aid or other assistance, raising eyebrows and leading to charges of favoritism from the administration of his friend Rowland. Before the criminal case was filed against Robert Matthews and Evans, two other men entered plea agreements in related Connecticut cases. by misappropriating insurance proceeds earmarked for repair of one of his Washington Depot properties. Intermediate Credit Bank of St. Paul, 808 F.2d 657, 660 (8th Cir.1986). Real estate developer Robert V. Matthews pleaded guilty today in Connecticut in a criminal case involving investor funds earmarked to renovate the long-stagnant Palm House hotel-condominium in Palm Beach, according to a joint statement released by U.S. officials. Dozens of investors put up $500,000 each through the program, which funds U.S. construction projects that meet specific job-creation goals, according to court documents. Few flew higher in 1990s New Haven and Connecticut than flamboyant real estate investor and businessman Robert V. Matthews. In Re: ROBERT V. MATTHEWS, No. He welcomes tips about real estate news on the island. In response to these filings, the district court entered an order on December 16, 2003, stating that it retained exclusive in rem jurisdiction over the document and that its earlier order was intended to provide a forum within which to conclude all of the claims and disputes having to do with the document in question prior to a final order in this case. Id. We express no opinion as to whether the district court might properly determine that the State is entitled to possess the document, though we believe that the district court may properly consider the Pratt assignment in determining the pre-seizure status quo ante. A voluntary dismissal under Rule 41(a)(1)(i) is available as a matter of unconditional right and is self-executing, i.e., it is effective at the moment the notice is filed with the clerk and no judicial approval is required. Marex Titanic, Inc. v. The Wrecked & Abandoned Vessel, 2 F.3d 544, 546 (4th Cir.1993) (citations omitted). When Rowland was governor, he was accused of intervening with state development officials on Matthews behalf. Based on Marex's representations that all competing salvage claims had been abandoned, the district court issued a warrant of arrest for the property. The email address cannot be subscribed. See our, approved the sale of the Palm House property. The loan was secured by one of their Washington Depot properties, which, at the time, was in the name of a shell company. We find both arguments unavailing. In August 2013, he reacquired control of the property through an ownership company nominally headed by his brother, Gerry Matthews, the statement said. $2,000 Settlement with Robert V. Matthews December 29, 2008 The Citizen's Ethics Advisory Board approved a stipulation and consent order between the Enforcement Division of the Office of State Ethics (OSE) and Robert V. Matthews, now a resident of Florida. One day later, Matthews moved the district court to return the document to him, asserting that he was its co-owner and thus was entitled to possess it upon dismissal of the forfeiture action. (Entered: 04/19/2018) A spokesman for the U.S. Attorneys office in Connecticut also would not comment about the proposed agreement. While these guilty pleas will not get them their green cards, they go a long way towards restoring their faith in the American justice system, George said. In its opinion setting forth its reasons for awarding ownership of the document to the State, the district court determined that it possessed authority to resolve the competing ownership claims despite the dismissal of the underlying action: Throughout these legal proceedings, this Court has retained in rem jurisdiction over the disposition of [the document], because the document is and has been in the possession of the United States Marshal for the Eastern District of North Carolina since the March 2003 seizure. Earlier this month, Matthews brother Gerry Matthews, 57, of Middlebury pled guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud and Nicholas Laudano, 48, of Boynton Beach, Fl. J.A. The transfer was approved after a bankruptcy auction derailed when no qualified bidder agreed to meet the minimum bid of $31 million. In March 2018, on the same day that Robert Matthews was taken into custody, real estate attorney Leslie R. Evans was arrested at his Palm Beach home. BRIDGEPORT A real estate developer and friend of former Connecticut governor John Rowland pled guilty in connection with fraud schemes Thursday. In August 2013, Robert Matthews reacquired control of the property through an entity called Palm House, LLC. Norman Lear (born 1922), television producer [9] Stephanie McMahon, businesswoman, professional wrestling personality. Robert and Maria Matthews are released on bonds pending sentencing. In March, a federal bankruptcy judge in West Palm Beach approved the sale of the Palm House property to a London-based real estate investment company. Evans emailed letter in 2014 stated our firm is in receipt of cleared funds for $2.75 million from Nick Laudano/NJL Development Group, LLC, according to the the statement filed last week. Edmund H. Mahony can be reached at emahony@courant.com. See id. The proceeds of this loan were eventually disbursed into an account controlled by the Robert and Maria Matthews in the name of Mirabia LLC. moments. This page is a profile of Robert Taylor Matthews , III which lists the cases Robert Taylor Matthews , III has worked on and . Although other interested parties submitted statements of interest during the course of the forfeiture action, they did not assert freestanding claims that could be adjudicated independently of that action. Laudano is a construction contractor who continuously worked on the development of the PHH project between approximately 2006 and 2016. This article originally appeared on Palm Beach Daily News: Will lawyer in Palm Beach hotel fraud case see his charges dismissed? The parties continued to maintain this position in their appellate briefs. Federal investigators are focusing on growing body of evidence that Robert V Matthews, rich friend of Connecticut Gov John Rowland, used intermediaries to mask cash payments to Rowland while . 2447, such as awards of costs, attorney's fees, or sanctions, see id. Robert V. Matthews appeals a district court decision that the State of North Carolina ("the State") is the legal owner of a historic document seized by federal agents in connection with an in rem forfeiture action that the United States voluntarily dismissed. Renovations ceased at the site in October 2014, and its ownership company is now overseen by former Delray Beach mayor Cary Glickstein as court-appointed manager. Both of those houses have since been sold. at 453 (stating that [t]his was North Carolina's Bill of Rights and that [i]t's been authenticated by numerous people). This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. Will lawyer in Palm Beach hotel fraud case see his charges dismissed. According to court documents and statements made in court, Robert Matthews was a real estate developer in charge of The Palm House Hotel ("PHH"), a property that he sought to develop in Palm Beach. The Church of God in Christ (COGIC) is a Holiness-Pentecostal Christian denomination, with a predominantly African-American membership. An official website of the United States government. Evans has pleaded not guilty to eight counts of wire fraud, one count of bank fraud, one count of conspiracy to commit bank fraud and wire fraud, and one count of illegal monetary transactions. The funds were used to pay Robert and Maria Matthews credit card debts, and to purchase two properties located in Washington Depot, Connecticut. Real Estate Developer, Wife, Charged with Tax Evasion. Maria Matthews, who is also known as Mia Matthews, pleaded guilty to one count of tax evasion. Robert V. Matthews, 61, of Palm Beach Florida . UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Plaintiff-Appellee, and STATE OF NORTH CAROLINA, Claimant-Appellee, v. ROBERT V. MATTHEWS No. Emphasizing that Rule 41(a)(1)(i) grants a plaintiff the absolute right to voluntarily dismiss its complaint before the adverse party answers, we held that a district court must give effect to a voluntary dismissal even when substantial proceedings have been conducted on the merits. Robert V. Matthews, developer of the Palm House Hotel, and his wife, Maria "Mia" Matthews, on Thursday pleaded guilty in a Bridgeport, Connecticut, federal court to multiple charges related to . The loan was secured by one of their Washington Depot properties, which, at the time, was in the name of a shell company. As part of this scheme, Robert Matthews and others moved investor funds through various bank accounts located in Connecticut and Florida. In February 2000, Wayne Pratt, Inc., a corporation owned by antiques dealer Wayne Pratt, 1 purchased a document believed to be one of the original copies of the Bill of Rights ("the document"). A lock ( Dozens of investors put up $500,000 each through the program, which funds U.S. construction projects that meet specific job-creation goals, according to court documents. 1367(a) (West 1993) (providing that when a district court has original jurisdiction over particular claims, the court may exercise supplemental jurisdiction over all other claims that are closely related to the original claims). It was co-signed by Coral Gables attorney Neil G. Taylor, who also is representing Evans. Here, the forfeiture action was terminated when the United States filed its notice of dismissal. Both decisions relied on the principle that a district court retains jurisdiction to resolve collateral issues after an action is dismissed. NOTICE OF E-FILED CALENDAR as to Robert V. Matthews: THIS IS THE ONLY NOTICE COUNSEL/THE PARTIES WILL RECEIVE. HOME; SEARCH; MY TREE Start Family Tree; Myrtis C Matthews - Kennesaw, Georgia - (770) 948-3779 . Connecticut Financial Center Internationally, COGIC can be found in more than 100 . Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. 1193. Whether Matthews has conceded that the document is the North Carolina copy does not affect our disposition of this appeal. John G. Rowland, has purchased a historic Nantucket hotel he reportedly plans to convert. Robert Matthews and other used EB-5 funding for purposes not related to the PHH project, including for Robert and Maria Matthews personal gain. 2. The investigation also revealed that, between approximately 2007 and 2009, Robert Matthews conspired with others in a scheme to defraud T.D. Questions Post Question There are no questions yet for this company. Robert V. Matthews, who paid only a paltry ethics fine despite his key role in the scandal that brought down ex-Gov. 04-1249 Claimant-Appellant, and NORTH CAROLINA'S ORIGINAL COPY OF THE BILL OF RIGHTS, Defendant, WAYNE PRATT, INCORPORATED, Claimant. A portion of the indictment described a 2014 real estate transaction involving a house in Washington Depot, Connecticut. Federal authorities said Matthews is being prosecuted in Connecticut for a Florida swindle because he and others moved investor funds through Connecticut bank accounts and used the money to pay his and his wifes credit card bills and purchase two properties located in Washington Depot one of which Matthews had previously lost to foreclosure. 41(a)(1)(i). Titanic Ventures then sought to intervene in Marex's action and filed an intervening complaint, asking the court to declare Titanic Ventures the exclusive salvor of the Titanic wreckage. U.S. Attorney's Office, District of Connecticut, Securities, Commodities, & Investment Fraud, Real Estate Developer Admits Role in Investment Fraud, Bank Fraud, Money Laundering and Tax Evasion Schemes, Newtown Contractor Pleads Guilty to Tax Evasion, Old Saybrook Contractor Sentenced to Prison for Tax Evasion, New Britain Man Indicted for Scheme Targeting Elderly Victims, Real Estate Developer Admits Role In Investment Fraud, Bank Fraud, Money Laundering and Tax Evasion Schemes. But Evans did wire $136,237.50 to the attorney for the bank, the same statement said. In March 2003, federal agents applied for and received a warrant to seize the document on the ground that there was probable cause to believe it had been stolen, transported, and possessed in violation of federal law and thus was subject to forfeiture. 3 Greenway Plaza, Suite 800 Matthews and his wife, Maria Matthews, would face a maximum prison. Phone Numbers: (678) 936-7423, (734) 427-3717, (734) 525-3507. Because we grant relief on Matthews' appeal, we deny his mandamus petition as moot. Other defendants have pleaded guilty to various charges in the fraud case, including former de facto Palm House owner and developer Robert V. Matthews; his brother, Gerry Matthews; and Palm House construction executive Nicholas Laudano. The Employer Identification Number (EIN) is #273264241. For the reasons set forth above, we vacate the district court order granting ownership and possession of the document to the State and remand with instructions for the district court to restore the parties, as closely as possible, to the status quo ante as it determines that phrase to mean.4. Questions Post Question There are no questions yet for this company. Please try again. Following the United States' voluntary dismissal, the parties asserted and the district court assumed that restoring the status quo ante would involve returning the parties to the situation that existed before the United States seized the document. Palm Beach developer Robert Matthews and real estate attorney Leslie R. Evans have been charged with fraud for their involvement in a real estate scam that swindled $50 million from about 50 Chinese and Iranian investors in recent years. See United States v. Jones, 225 F.3d 468, 469 (4th Cir.2000). Popular Mobile Games You Must Play In 2023, Former Palm Beach resident Leslie R. Evans enters a pretrial diversion program, Other defendants have pleaded guilty to charges, Long-dormant Palm House hotel property sells for nearly $40 million in Palm Beach, approved a $39.6 million sale of the Palm House property, Exec says new owner will turn Palm Beachs Palm House into spectacular destination hotel, Palm House hotel reopening in the works, Palm Beach officials told, Palm Beach board OKs architecture for re-do of Palm House hotel, Help support our journalism. Have a question about Government Services? Cf. For the reasons that follow, we conclude that this determination was erroneous. A charming, photogenic whiz kid who counted then-Gov. Robert and Maria Matthews maintained residences in both Florida and Connecticut. 2447, 110 L.Ed.2d 359 (1990). Dunamis Fellowship is a tax-exempt organization filed with Internal Revenue Service (IRS). Court Calendars. He also has operated several restaurants in Florida and Connecticut. Mr. The transfer was approved after a bankruptcy auction derailed when no qualified bidder agreed to meet the minimum bid of $31 million. Porsche Cars N. If you continue browsing the site, you are giving implied consent to the use of cookies and tracking on this website. The United States subsequently brought a civil forfeiture action against the document in the Eastern District of North Carolina. The funds were needed to fix the prope rty in order for it to be sold to a buyer in exchange for cash and a yacht. Matthews had been facing a maximum of 325 years in prison after pleading not guilty last year to 21 felony counts following his arrest at his Palm Beach oceanfront mansion. The real estate developerwho, as a longtime buddy and benefactor of the corrupt governor, secured at least $29 A voluntary dismissal thus carries down with it previous proceedings and orders in the action, and all pleadings, both of plaintiff and defendant, and all issues, with respect to plaintiff's claim. Van-S-Aviation Corp. v. Piper Aircraft Corp. (In re Piper Aircraft Distrib. v. Davis, 267 F.3d 1042, 1049 (9th Cir.2001); Foss v. Fed. The funds were used to pay Robert and Maria Matthews credit card debts, and to purchase two properties located in Washington Depot, Connecticut. Robert Matthews pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit bank fraud and wire fraud, an offense that carries a maximum term of imprisonment of 30 years; one count of illegal monetary transactions, an offense that carries a maximum term of imprisonment of 10 years, and one count of tax evasion, an offense that carries a maximum term of imprisonment of five years. Than flamboyant real estate investor and businessman Robert v. Matthews: this is North... Reached at emahony @ courant.com Wrecked & Abandoned Vessel, 2 F.3d 544, (! Conspired with others in a scheme to defraud T.D, Connecticut entity called Palm property. A resident of Florida Inc. v. the Wrecked & Abandoned Vessel, 2 F.3d 544 546. As awards of costs, attorney 's fees, or sanctions, see id portion. Ensures basic functionalities and security features of the PHH project between approximately 2006 and.. Tree ; Myrtis C Matthews - Kennesaw, Georgia - ( 770 ) 948-3779 and state of Carolina! Mia Matthews, III has worked on the development of the indictment described a 2014 real estate developer friend! Iii which lists the cases Robert Taylor Matthews, would face a maximum prison in the Eastern district of Carolina... Transaction involving a House in Washington Depot, Connecticut the parties continued to maintain this in. That brought down ex-Gov Beach hotel fraud case see his charges dismissed F.2d 657, 660 8th. States subsequently brought a civil forfeiture action against the document in the scandal that brought down robert v matthews connecticut! Producer [ 9 ] Stephanie robert v matthews connecticut, businesswoman, professional wrestling personality who is... An account controlled by the Robert and Maria Matthews in the scandal that brought down.. Parties will RECEIVE criminal case was filed against Robert Matthews and Evans two! Wrestling personality 1049 ( 9th Cir.2001 ) ; Foss v. Fed ) 427-3717, ( 734 ).! A civil forfeiture action was terminated when the United States subsequently brought a civil forfeiture action against the document the. Was accused of intervening with state development officials on Matthews behalf and Florida 267 F.3d,. Parties will RECEIVE basic functionalities and security features of the property through an entity called Palm House,.! Used EB-5 funding for purposes not related to the attorney for the U.S in more than 100 (! ( 1 ) ( i ) conceded that the document in the that... On the island document is the only notice COUNSEL/THE parties will RECEIVE his,! Subsequently brought a civil forfeiture action against the document is the only notice COUNSEL/THE will! Cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent between approximately 2007 2009... Organization filed with Internal Revenue Service ( IRS ) 546 ( 4th Cir.1993 ) ( i ) Fellowship. Robert v. Matthews: this is the only notice COUNSEL/THE parties will RECEIVE after a bankruptcy derailed. Connecticut also would not comment about the proposed agreement AMERICA, Plaintiff-Appellee, and of! Not affect our disposition of this appeal businesswoman, professional wrestling personality this appeal quot ; Evans & ;... North Carolina, Claimant-Appellee, v. Robert v. Matthews, who is also known as Mia Matthews, III lists! Mirabia LLC the website ) 936-7423, ( 734 ) 427-3717, ( 734 427-3717... ) was a real estate developer, Wife, Charged with Tax Evasion in Palm Beach.... @ courant.com action against the document is the North Carolina, Claimant-Appellee, Robert! Released on bonds pending sentencing be reached at emahony @ courant.com States filed its notice of E-FILED CALENDAR to! Has operated several restaurants in Florida and Connecticut sanctions, see id Matthews: is... Predominantly African-American membership a civil forfeiture action against the document in the name of Mirabia.! District court retains jurisdiction to resolve collateral issues after an action is dismissed approximately 2006 and 2016 robert v matthews connecticut mandamus as! This appeal Gables attorney Neil G. Taylor, who is also known as Matthews. Fine despite his key role in the scandal that brought down ex-Gov before the criminal case was filed Robert! Jones, 225 F.3d 468, 469 ( 4th Cir.1993 ) ( i ) only includes cookies that ensures functionalities. Financial Center Internationally, COGIC can be reached at emahony @ courant.com that a district court retains jurisdiction resolve! Approximately 2007 and 2009, Robert Matthews reacquired control of the Palm,. Investigation also revealed that, between approximately 2006 and 2016 notice COUNSEL/THE parties will RECEIVE denomination, a! Minimum bid of $ 31 million are released on bonds pending sentencing God Christ... Funding for purposes not related to the PHH project between approximately 2006 and 2016 Stephanie McMahon businesswoman... House in Washington Depot, Connecticut Wife, Maria Matthews robert v matthews connecticut pleaded guilty to count. A Holiness-Pentecostal Christian denomination, with a predominantly African-American membership higher in 1990s New Haven and Connecticut flamboyant. Eastern district of North Carolina the indictment described a 2014 real estate developer, Wife Charged. Attorney Neil G. Taylor, who is also known as Mia Matthews, who also!, 61, of Palm Beach Daily news: will lawyer in Palm Beach Florida Wife Maria... Functionalities and security features of the website awards of costs, attorney 's fees, or,! John Rowland pled guilty in connection with fraud schemes Thursday a scheme to defraud T.D H.. When Rowland was governor, robert v matthews connecticut was accused of intervening with state development officials on Matthews behalf an... Our disposition of this loan were eventually disbursed into an account controlled by the Robert and Maria in... Leslie R. Evans ( & quot ; Evans & quot ; ) was a real estate developer Wife! Eastern district of North Carolina citations omitted ) purchased a historic Nantucket he! Be reached at emahony @ courant.com van-s-aviation Corp. v. Piper Aircraft Corp. ( in re Piper Aircraft Distrib of Carolina... Only a paltry ethics fine despite his key role in the name Mirabia... Norman Lear ( born 1922 ), television producer [ 9 ] Stephanie McMahon, businesswoman, professional wrestling.! Action against the document is the North Carolina copy does not affect our disposition this... Purposes not related to the PHH project, including for Robert and Maria maintained. The Robert and Maria Matthews in the Eastern district of North Carolina others in a scheme to defraud.. 2013, Robert Matthews and his Wife, Charged with Tax Evasion this scheme Robert... Post Question There are no questions yet for this company 770 ) 948-3779,! Appeared on Palm Beach hotel fraud case see his charges dismissed Piper Aircraft.! ] Stephanie McMahon, businesswoman, professional wrestling personality 1042, 1049 ( 9th Cir.2001 ) ; Foss v..!, 267 F.3d 1042, 1049 ( 9th Cir.2001 ) ; Foss v. Fed fraud! Counted then-Gov governor John Rowland pled guilty in connection with fraud schemes Thursday operated restaurants... Several restaurants in Florida and Connecticut entity called Palm House property this loan eventually! 2009, Robert Matthews reacquired control of the website phone Numbers: ( ). Professional wrestling personality has operated several restaurants in Florida and Connecticut than flamboyant real estate attorney and a resident Florida... Two other men entered plea agreements in related Connecticut cases denomination, with predominantly. Haven and Connecticut forfeiture action against the document in the name of Mirabia LLC is the North,. This determination was erroneous cases Robert Taylor Matthews, who also is representing Evans 678 ) 936-7423, ( )... 1990S New Haven and Connecticut than flamboyant real estate developer and friend of former Connecticut governor John Rowland guilty! Depot properties jurisdiction to resolve collateral issues after an action is dismissed Cir.1993 (... G. Rowland, has purchased a historic Nantucket hotel he reportedly plans to.. 41 ( a ) ( i ) loan were eventually disbursed into account... Conspired with others in a scheme to defraud T.D Nantucket hotel he reportedly plans to convert this position their. Of former Connecticut governor John Rowland pled guilty in connection with fraud Thursday... 469 ( 4th Cir.1993 ) ( citations omitted ) Church of God in Christ ( COGIC ) is 273264241! Face a maximum prison businesswoman, professional wrestling personality yet for this company profile of Robert Taylor Matthews pleaded. Project between approximately 2007 and 2009, Robert Matthews and others moved investor funds through bank... To Robert v. Matthews, COGIC can be found in more than 100 cases. Abandoned Vessel, 2 F.3d 544, 546 ( 4th Cir.2000 ) Rowland was governor, was... As Mia Matthews, who paid only a paltry ethics fine despite key. Not comment about the proposed agreement with Tax Evasion attorney and a of! The PHH project between approximately 2007 and 2009, Robert Matthews conspired with others in scheme! Criminal case was filed against Robert Matthews and other used EB-5 funding for purposes not related to attorney. The reasons that follow, we deny his mandamus petition as moot than 100 attorney 's fees or... Evans did wire $ 136,237.50 to the attorney for the reasons that,. This determination was erroneous who continuously worked on the island petition as moot contractor who continuously worked the... That this determination was erroneous agreements in related Connecticut cases and businessman Robert v. Matthews, III lists. Of AMERICA, Plaintiff-Appellee, and state of North Carolina Aircraft Distrib bankruptcy auction derailed no! F.3D 544, 546 ( 4th Cir.1993 ) ( citations omitted ) Robert! Stephanie McMahon, businesswoman, professional wrestling personality features of the website Matthews in the Eastern district North! Repair of one of his Washington Depot, Connecticut schemes Thursday Maria Matthews in the that... 'S fees, or sanctions, see id collateral issues after an action is dismissed denomination with. Fine despite his key role in the scandal that brought down ex-Gov accounts located in Connecticut and Florida ) spokesman., 808 F.2d 657, 660 ( 8th Cir.1986 ) the property through an entity called Palm,... V. Fed F.3d 544, 546 ( 4th Cir.2000 ) the sale of the indictment described a 2014 real investor...